Take profit vs stop loss: what each exit changes in a backtest
A stop loss caps the loss of one trade and a take profit caps its gain. The stop lowers the win rate and the average loss, the target raises the win rate and shrinks the average win. Whether a target helps depends on where the strategy's profit lives in its trade list, so test the baseline first, then the stop, then the target.
By Soren Huang · Published · updated · Editorial policy
Contents
- What does a take profit do that a stop loss does not?
- Should you set a take profit at all?
- What take profit ratio is typical?
- Is a stop loss alone enough?
- How do take profit and stop loss change win rate, drawdown and trade count?
- What does a baseline with no stop or target look like?
- How does position size interact with the exits?
- How should you test take profit and stop loss settings?
- Frequently asked questions
- References
What does a take profit do that a stop loss does not?
Take profit vs stop loss: a stop loss caps how much one trade can lose, a take profit caps how much it can gain. The stop lowers the average loss and the win rate; the target raises the win rate and lowers the average win. Together they fix the shape of every trade before the entry rule has any say.
A stop loss is an order that closes the trade once price has moved against it by a set distance. A take profit is an order that closes the trade once price has moved in its favour by a set distance. Think of a corridor with a wall on each side. The entry puts you in the corridor, and the trade ends when price touches either wall. The stop wall decides the worst single trade you can have. The target wall decides the best. The mechanics of the stop order itself, and why a stop on futures can fill past its price, are covered in how a stop loss order works on futures.
Hypothetical example
A long ES entry at 5,000 with a stop at 4,980 and a target at 5,040. ES moves $50 per index point, so the stop allows a loss of 20 points, or $1,000 per contract before costs, and the target allows a gain of 40 points, or $2,000 per contract. Whatever the entry rule was, every trade in this backtest now ends at one of three places: −$1,000, +$2,000, or somewhere in between if a signal or the session close ends it first.
Should you set a take profit at all?
A take profit helps a strategy whose profit comes from many small moves and hurts one whose profit comes from a few large moves, so the answer comes from the shape of the trade list, not from habit. The claim running through this article is that no exit setting improves every number at once; a target is the clearest case.
Sort the trades of a baseline run from largest winner to largest loser and look at the two ends. A trend-following list usually has many small losses and a short list of large wins that hold most of the net profit. A target placed at a fixed distance cuts exactly those large wins, so the win rate goes up and the net profit goes down. A mean-reversion list is the opposite: results cluster around small wins, with an occasional large loss when the market keeps going. There the same target removes almost nothing, and the stop is the exit that matters. Kaminski and Lo (2014) reach a related conclusion for stops: a stop rule adds value when losses tend to continue and subtracts value when prices tend to come back.
A quick check before any grid: add up the profit of the largest 10 percent of winning trades and divide it by the net profit. If that share is well above half, a fixed target will cost more than it saves, and a trailing stop or a signal exit is the better way to protect open profit.
What take profit ratio is typical?
Most systematic traders test targets between 1 and 3 times the stop distance, because the ratio fixes the win rate the strategy must reach to break even, and the maximum favourable excursion shows how far trades actually travel. The ratio is target distance divided by stop distance; a 40-point target with a 20-point stop is 2:1.
The one formula worth keeping is:
break-even win rate = 1 ÷ (1 + ratio)
Here ratio is the target distance divided by the stop distance, and the break-even win rate is the share of winning trades at which the wins exactly pay for the losses before costs. A 1:1 ratio needs half the trades to win. A 2:1 ratio needs one in three. A 3:1 ratio needs one in four. A 0.5:1 ratio, where the target is closer than the stop, needs two in three. Commission and slippage push each of these higher, because every trade pays costs whether it wins or loses.
The ratio you can reach is limited by how far trades travel. Maximum favourable excursion (MFE) is the largest open profit a trade showed before it closed. If most baseline trades never showed more than 30 points of open profit, a 60-point target will rarely fill and the backtest will behave as if there were no target. The method for reading a target from the MFE distribution is in how to set profit targets from maximum favorable excursion.
Is a stop loss alone enough?
A stop alone is enough when the strategy already has an exit rule that closes trades on its own signal; the target becomes necessary only when that exit rule gives back most of the open profit. Three exit designs are worth telling apart, because each ends winners and losers for a different reason.
| Design | Signal exit only | Stop loss only | Stop loss plus take profit |
|---|---|---|---|
| What ends a winner | Opposite signal or session close | Opposite signal, after giving some profit back | Target, or signal if first |
| What ends a loser | Opposite signal, however late | Stop at a known distance | Stop at a known distance |
| Average win | Largest of the three | Similar to signal only | Smaller, capped at the target |
| Win rate | Set by the signal | Lower, stops take trades the signal might have saved | Higher, targets lock in small wins |
| Holding time | Longest | Shorter on losers | Shortest on both sides |
The middle column is the usual place to start. A stop closes the trades the signal would have held too long, while the signal still lets winners run. Measure how much open profit the signal exit gives back: compare the average MFE of winning trades with their average closed profit. If the closed profit is less than half the MFE, the exit is slow, and a target or a trailing stop is worth testing. The choice between a fixed-tick stop, an ATR stop, a time stop and a trailing stop is laid out in stop loss choices for a systematic futures strategy.
How do take profit and stop loss change win rate, drawdown and trade count?
A tighter stop lowers the win rate, raises the trade count and shortens the loss of each trade, while a closer target raises the win rate and shrinks the average win, so no setting improves every number at once. The arrows in the figure below are the ones to expect before you run any grid.
Two of these effects are often misread. First, a tighter stop makes each loss smaller but does not by itself make the maximum drawdown smaller. Maximum drawdown is the largest fall from an equity peak to the next low, and a run of twelve small stopped-out trades can fall as far as three large signal-exit losses. The drawdown per trade shrinks; the drawdown of the strategy may not. Second, both exits raise the trade count, because the strategy is flat sooner and can take the next signal. More trades means more commission and slippage, which is why the average trade after costs is the number to watch while the win rate moves.
| Report number | Stop moved closer | Target moved closer |
|---|---|---|
| Win rate | Down | Up |
| Average loss | Down | Unchanged |
| Average win | Roughly unchanged | Down |
| Trade count | Up | Up |
| Maximum drawdown | Either direction | Either direction |
| Average trade after costs | Depends on the trade list | Depends on the trade list |
What does a baseline with no stop or target look like?
An ES daily run with a Rate Of Change rule as its only entry and exit shows the trade list that any stop or target would then reshape, and its drawdown shows what a signal-only exit allows. The run below tested ES daily bars from 2019-01-02 to 2025-06-30, long and short, one contract, with $20 commission and $25 slippage charged on every trade. The Rate Of Change indicator is a stand-in rule built from a standard indicator, not the subject of this article; it is here to produce a trade list with no stop and no target, so that both exits have a baseline to be measured against.
Source: AlphaPrime product engine (CPU), run 2026-10-31. ES daily bars, 2019-01-02 to 2025-06-30, long and short, 1 contract, $20 commission and $25 slippage per trade.
| Number | Result |
|---|---|
| Net profit (closed trades) | $68,585 |
| Max drawdown | $64,677.5 |
| Trades | 47 |
| Win rate | 57.45% |
| Profit factor | 1.638 |
| Average trade | $1,459.26 |
| Time in market | 94.01% |
This is one candidate kept out of 1,024 that the search tried (the run's own count), chosen for its return against its drawdown. Picking the kept one after the fact flatters it, as Bailey et al. (2014) show for any best-of-many backtest, so the numbers describe this trade list and nothing more; they are not what the rule earns or what a reader can expect. What the list says about exits is still useful. Time in market of 94.01% means the strategy was almost always holding a position, which is what a signal-only exit allows: a trade runs until the opposite signal, however long that takes. Max drawdown of $64,677.5 against net profit of $68,585 says that some trades gave back a great deal before the signal closed them. The trade list and drawdown chart in the Performance Report of AlphaPrime (Valynox) let you find those trades and read how far each went against the entry before it closed, which is the raw material for the stop grid in the last section.
How does position size interact with the exits?
With the same entries and exits, nine sizing methods produce very different drawdowns, and the stop distance is the input that risk-based sizing uses, so the stop decision and the size decision are one decision. The free position size calculator shows this directly: enter an account risk per trade and a stop distance, and the contract count falls out. Halve the stop and the same risk allows twice the contracts, which doubles the gain or loss of every trade that ends on a signal rather than on the stop.
Hypothetical example
Account risk of $1,000 per trade on ES. With a 20-point stop, one contract loses $1,000 at the stop, so the size is one contract. With a 10-point stop, the size becomes two contracts. A trade that then runs 30 points in your favour and exits on a signal makes $1,500 with the wide stop and $3,000 with the tight stop. The tight stop also gets hit more often, so the win rate drops while the average win rises. The stop setting changed four report numbers without touching the entry rule.
The second box applies nine money-management methods to the same 47 trades as the baseline above, with $100,000 of capital and at most 10 contracts, each method on its report defaults. The entries and exits are identical in every row, so every difference in the table comes from sizing alone.
Source: AlphaPrime product engine (CPU), run 2026-10-31. Same trades as the box above, capital $100,000, at most 10 contracts.
| Method | Net profit | Max drawdown | Average contracts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed contracts | $207,635 | $193,753 | 3 |
| Fixed notional | $177,785 | $178,415 | 2.51 |
| Percent of equity | $80,948 | $257,830 | 2.74 |
| Fixed dollar risk | $226,410 | $152,078 | 2.81 |
| Fixed fractional risk | $232,473 | $484,718 | 4.26 |
| Volatility target | $226,410 | $152,078 | 2.81 |
| Fixed ratio | $149,898 | $240,955 | 2.53 |
| Equity curve trading | $244,623 | $98,870 | 2.19 |
| Kelly | $52,923 | $72,760 | 1.02 |
Read the drawdown column against the $100,000 of capital. Six of the nine methods show a maximum drawdown larger than the starting capital, which means the account would have been empty before the run ended; the net profit in those rows was never reachable. The risk-based rows (fixed dollar risk and volatility target coincided in this run) are the ones whose contract count depends on a stop or volatility distance, so when you later add a stop, these rows change size on every trade. A stop measured in ATR units keeps that size steady as volatility changes; ATR trailing stops and position size shows how the two settings are tied.
How should you test take profit and stop loss settings?
Run the baseline first, then a stop grid, then a target grid on top of the chosen stop, and keep only settings that sit on a flat plateau of neighbours, checked against the MAE and MFE of the baseline trades. The order matters because each step uses the output of the one before it.
- Run the baseline with the signal exit only. Record, for every trade, the maximum adverse excursion (MAE), which is the largest open loss the trade showed before it closed, and the MFE. These two numbers tell you where stops and targets would have fired.
- Test a grid of stop distances in ATR units. Place the grid where the MAE distribution says winners and losers part ways: a stop inside the MAE of most winning trades will cut them. How to read that point from the MAE distribution is explained in reading a stop from maximum adverse excursion.
- Fix the stop and test target ratios from 1:1 to 3:1 in steps of 0.5. Compare each row with the stop-only row on average trade after costs, not on win rate.
- Keep only settings whose neighbours behave alike. A parameter plateau is a region of neighbouring settings that all give similar results; a single stop distance that works while the next ones up and down fail is a lucky spike. Pardo (2008) treats this plateau test as a requirement of any optimization, not an extra.
- Rerun the kept setting once on data no grid has touched. Read the result against a pass rule written before the run, and accept or reject.
A grid of ten stop distances and five target ratios is fifty runs of the same strategy on top of the baseline, and each one has to charge the same commission, slippage and next-bar fill as the baseline or the rows are not comparable. Write down, before step 2, the share of the baseline average trade you require the final setting to keep after costs, so the decision at step 5 is made by that number and not by the look of the equity curve.
The next thing to do is step 1: take your current strategy, remove its stop and target, run it once, and sort the trades by MFE. If the top tenth of winners holds most of the net profit, the target you are about to test is already answered.
Frequently asked questions
Should the take profit be bigger than the stop loss?
Not necessarily. A target twice the stop needs one trade in three to win before costs, while a target equal to the stop needs one in two. Which ratio works depends on how far the strategy's trades actually travel, which the MFE of a baseline run shows. A large target that trades rarely reach behaves as if there were no target at all.
Can a stop loss be too tight?
Yes. A stop placed inside the normal adverse excursion of winning trades closes trades that would have ended in profit, so the win rate falls faster than the average loss does. The MAE of the baseline trades shows how far winners typically move against the entry before they turn; a stop sits outside most of that distance. Testing neighbouring stop distances shows whether the chosen one is on a plateau or on a spike.
Does a take profit improve the win rate?
A take profit usually raises the win rate, because it locks in trades that reached the target and would otherwise have given some profit back. The cost is a smaller average win, since the largest winners are cut at the target. The number to compare before and after is the average trade after costs; a higher win rate with a lower average trade is a worse result.
What is the difference between a stop loss and a take profit order?
A stop loss is an order that closes the trade when price moves against it by a set distance; a take profit closes the trade when price moves in its favour by a set distance. The stop fixes the largest loss one trade can have, the target fixes the largest gain. On futures a stop becomes a market order when touched and can fill past its price, while a take profit is a limit order that fills at its price or better but only if the market trades there.
References
- Bailey, D. H., Borwein, J., López de Prado, M., & Zhu, Q. J. (2014). Pseudo-Mathematics and Financial Charlatanism: The Effects of Backtest Overfitting on Out-of-Sample Performance. Notices of the American Mathematical Society, 61(5), 458–471.
- Kaminski, K. M., & Lo, A. W. (2014). When Do Stop-Loss Rules Stop Losses? Journal of Financial Markets, 18, 234–254.
- Pardo, R. (2008). The Evaluation and Optimization of Trading Strategies (2nd ed.). John Wiley & Sons.

